We’ve closely monitored and opposed an application by the West Park Presbyterian Church on the Upper West Side for a “hardship” claim that would allow them to demolish their historic, landmarked structure. Landmarking does and should allow for exceptions to its requirements when no reasonable way exists to maintain a structure, and it’s impossible for an owner to make a reasonable return upon it or, in the case of a nonprofit, to fulfill its mission with it. 

However, like many of our colleagues, community leaders, and elected officials who’ve led this effort, we don’t believe West Park has in any way demonstrated that is the case through this process. And it’s critical that they, or any other applicant, be rigorously required to do so before an exemption is granted and options like demolition are considered. Otherwise, preserving landmarked structures becomes optional, which any owner can avoid by simply saying they don’t like the requirements attached to it (we’re already seeking the City’s Parks Department pursue a similar path with the landmarked Tony Dapolito Recreation Center — help stop that HERE). 

That’s why we were so troubled last week when the Landmarks Preservation Commission indicated they were inclined to grant West Park’s hardship application. While a final vote has not occurred, signs are bad that the Commission’s decision, reversing years of precedent and practice, will further dismantle landmark protections, as we’ve seen happening with other changes being proposed and implemented across our city and country. 

We will continue to closely monitor this and keep you posted.